An Analytical Reassessment of Olbers’ Paradox: FLRW Cosmology and a Conditional Propagation-Redshift Toy Model
Bhaktaraj Thiyam *
Department of Mathematics, Manipur International University, Imphal, India.
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Abstract
Olbers’ paradox is a useful convergence test for cosmological radiation fields because an infinite, homogeneous, eternal and static population of identical luminous sources produces a divergent bolometric flux in Euclidean space. This analytical study compares that classical result with the standard Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) background-intensity formulation and a deliberately restricted propagation-redshift toy model. In FLRW cosmology, the observed bolometric background follows from comoving luminosity density, luminosity distance, comoving volume and the expansion history; a finite source history, source evolution, cosmological redshift and geometry jointly invalidate the assumptions of the classical static construction. For the alternative toy model, the local postulate d ln \(\lambda\)/ds = c-1 |du/dr | is examined for \(u(r)=-\sqrt{2 G M /r}\). The resulting single-domain redshift approaches a finite asymptote and therefore cannot regularise the classical Olbers integral for any finite positive flux-redshift exponent q. A deterministic cumulative ansatz, 1+z = exp(\(\alpha\)r), is then analysed only as a conditional mathematical construction. It yields F = nL/(k + q\(\alpha\)) when k + q\(\alpha\) > 0. A new stochastic-domain extension shows that a positive mean logarithmic redshift increment alone is insufficient for ensemblemean convergence: for independent increments Y = ln(1 + \(\delta\)), the relevant quantity is mq = E[e-qY ] = E[(1 + \(\delta\))−q]. Without attenuation, ensemble-mean convergence requires mq < 1 in both fixed-density and Poisson domain-count models. The model is further confronted analytically with luminosity-distance curvature, supernova time dilation, Tolman surface-brightness dimming, baryon acoustic oscillation distance information, CMB spectral preservation and extragalactic background-light constraints. These comparisons reinforce the conclusion that the propagation construction is a falsifiable toy model rather than an observationally established alternative to FLRW/ΛCDM.
Keywords: Olbers’ paradox, FLRW cosmology, cosmological redshift, luminosity distance, extragalactic background light, photon propagation, convergence, stochastic domains